data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5c16b/5c16bd7ba717a85a337b05a19dde59b1639f8a4e" alt="Code chicken core mc"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/14404/1440484fc6ff755844a81eccc1285476ca1092b7" alt="code chicken core mc code chicken core mc"
Wendy's Classic Chicken Sandwich.Our least favorite. I thought there was a little too much batter for the amount of chicken. My daughter didn't like the texture of the chicken, which she found a little rubbery. The bun has good flavor and holds together well. Mouth-watering crunch when you bite into it. Popeyes Classic Chicken Sandwich. This one ignited the chicken sandwich wars in 2019. Here are our impressions, in the order that we visited the restaurants. There's no apparent correlation between price and weight, and all cost less than $4.50.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/92896/9289665178f9890b164449288da9ecd2079148b2" alt="code chicken core mc code chicken core mc"
Chick-fil-A had the smallest sandwich at just over half the weight of KFC. KFC had the biggest sandwich by weight at 10.3oz (291g) followed by Popeyes at 8.6oz (245g). (I'm ignoring fiber here because these sandwiches contain little fiber.) If two sandwiches were to weigh the same and have the same water content, but one had more fat, then it would also have more calories. We weighed the sandwiches to approximate calories. Carbohydrate and protein contain 4 calories per gram, fat contains 9 calories per gram, and water contains 0 calories per gram, so weight differences would be a good indicator of calorie differences if each sandwich had the same proportions of fat and water. We decided to roll with it rather than going back to correct the order. McDonald's threw off our plans by giving us spicy sandwiches even though we ordered the regular. That means no spicy sandwiches (even though we like spicy) and no adding jalapenos or extra sauce or whatever. We chose the standard chicken sandwich because we wanted to evaluate the core product. We also rated the fries and nuggets/tenders. We started out very hungry and ended up very full. Starting at noon on Saturday, we drove from Davis to Popeyes and Wendy's in Dixon (15 minutes), then to Chick-fil-A in Vacaville (15 minutes), then to McDonald's in Dixon (15 minutes), and finally to KFC in Davis (15 minutes).
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/405f8/405f8dbb463ceb9b442a86f414e7d869aa6142a6" alt="code chicken core mc code chicken core mc"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/ef6af/ef6afdaa22e8868e7584dfe3cb4bc8a23a3da0f6" alt="code chicken core mc code chicken core mc"
At each restaurant's drive through, get two standard chicken sandwiches, a small fries, and a small order of nuggets/tenders.Visit all restaurants on the same afternoon.So, who makes the best sandwich? To answer this question as objectively as possible, and inspired by this article, my daughter and I formulated the following research protocol:
Code chicken core mc code#
Source: USDA ERS and R Code linked at end of article Americans now eat more chicken than beef and pork combined. Beef and pork consumption declined over the same period. We did not agree on the best sandwich, but we did agree on the worst.Ĭhicken consumption in the US has tripled in the last 60 years from 30 pounds per person per year in 1960 to over 90 pounds now. We are not the first to run this experiment, but it was fun and we learned things. We evaluated Popeyes, Wendy's, Chick-fil-A, McDonald's, and KFC. Last weekend, my daughter and I embarked on a mission to discover which chain makes the best chicken sandwich. McDonald's and KFC unveiled new chicken sandwiches last month in an attempt to keep up. Then, in 2019 Popeyes launched a new chicken sandwich that almost immediately sold out, sparking a sharp response from Chick-fil-A. Chick-fil-A tripled its sales between 20 becoming the nation's third largest restaurant chain behind McDonald's and Starbucks. Americans are eating more chicken than ever before, so it comes as no surprise that fast food chains now compete over chicken rather than burgers.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/5c16b/5c16bd7ba717a85a337b05a19dde59b1639f8a4e" alt="Code chicken core mc"